The Pros and Cons of Taking Social Security at 62, 67 and 70

Deciding when to start your Social Security benefits is one of the most consequential choices you will ever make. It dictates your monthly income for the rest of your life, influences your spouse’s survivor benefits, and shifts your overall tax picture.

There is no single correct age to file. The system is designed to pay out roughly the same total amount over an average lifetime regardless of when you start. The math changes based on your health, your savings and whether you plan to keep working.

Let’s look at the advantages and drawbacks of the three major claiming milestones.

Claiming early at age 62

Age 62 is typically the very first opportunity you have to claim your retirement benefits. It is a popular choice, often driven by fear, but it comes with a steep permanent cost.

• The pros: You get your money as soon as possible. If you are in poor health or have a family history of shorter lifespans, claiming early ensures you receive benefits while you can use them. It can also provide a crucial lifeline if you lose your job and cannot find new employment, allowing you to pay bills without draining your investment accounts.
• The cons: You face a permanent reduction in your monthly check. If your Full Retirement Age is 67, claiming at 62 means taking a 30% permanent cut to your baseline benefit.
• The earnings penalty: If you claim early and continue working, you run into the earnings test. The government will temporarily withhold a portion of your benefits if your income from work exceeds a specific annual limit. While you eventually get this money back in the form of higher checks later in life, it defeats the purpose of claiming early to boost your current income.

Waiting for full retirement age at 67

For anyone born in 1960 or later, age 67 is your Full Retirement Age. This is the age the government considers you eligible for your standard, unreduced benefit amount.

• The pros: You receive 100% of your full benefit amount. Reaching this age also eliminates the earnings test. You can work as much as you want, earn a high salary, and still collect your full Social Security check every month without any withholding penalties.
• The cons: You have to wait five years past your initial eligibility date. If you have a shorter life expectancy, you might leave money on the table compared to someone who claimed at 62 and collected checks for those five gap years.

Delaying for the maximum payout at 70

Every year you delay claiming past your Full Retirement Age, the government rewards you with delayed retirement credits. These credits stop accumulating when you turn 70.

• The pros: You maximize your guaranteed monthly income. For every year you postpone claiming beyond your full retirement age, you see an 8% increase to your baseline benefit. This is a guaranteed 8% annual return — which is exceptionally difficult to find risk-free in the open market. Furthermore, if you are the higher earner in a marriage, delaying until 70 maximizes the survivor’s benefit your spouse will receive if you pass away first.
• The cons: It requires patience and alternative funding. You have to fund your lifestyle from your own savings or wages throughout your late 60s. You also need to live long enough to reach the break-even point: Generally, you need to live into your early 80s for the total amount of your checks over the course of your retirement to exceed the total amount you would have collected by starting earlier.

Finding your personal sweet spot

Look at your health, your marriage and your bank accounts. If you have health issues or need the money to survive, claiming at 62 is a perfectly logical choice.

If you have longevity in your family and sufficient savings to bridge the gap, waiting until 70 is smart. It provides the highest possible floor for your guaranteed income late in life, when you are least able to go back to work.

Review your latest statements directly from the government, run the numbers for your specific household, and coordinate the timing with your spouse.